What broker is performing the best?
It’s a question that I get a lot and it’s quite hard to say one is better than another because what happens today may not be true tomorrow. The most frustrating thing about rating brokers is that their trading conditions change over time. What works today, may not work tomorrow. From my experience, I’ve seen good brokers go bad. Just remember that most brokers are not a True ECN Straight Through Processing exchange and as a result, brokers have a reason to short change you. From slippage, execution delays, server outages, and spread increases these tactics whether you like or not earns a significant bonus for the brokerage.
What I’ve done today is compared several popular FX brokerages that trade the signals from Forex i007. The statistics are only taken from yesterday’s performance but it still is enough to see the difference among the brokers. I’ve put in account the GMT offset from each brokers server and selected a 29 hour trading window which took place from GMT+0 May 2nd,2012 00:00 til May 3rd, 2012 05:00
- Forex i007 Broker Comparison
- IBFX – Master Account – 41 trades – 307.7 pips no commission
- Pepperstone Razor – 41 trades – 387.5 pips – commission($7rt)
- Hotforex STP – 41 trades – 377 pips – commission($10rt)
- Pepperstone Std – 41 trades – 362.4 pips no commission
- Finfx Pro – 37 trades – 324 pips – commission($7rt)
- ATC – 37 trades – 310.6 pips – commission($8rt)
- ThinkForex – 40 trades – 299 pips no commission
- ILQ – 37 trades – 284 pips no commission
- PFG – 39 trades – 207.5 pips no commission
After considering commission fees, Pepperstone Standard account actually outperformed all the other brokers by a long shot. Through the last several months Pepperstone has been the most inconsistent broker because of the server outages, but yesterday must have been a solid connection and every signal was a success. Also when doing the GMT time adjustments and checking all the comments/magic numbers, I could have made a few mistakes. Overall its still interesting to see the comparison at the end of the day. In the past Thinkforex normally outperformed most brokers after considering the commission cost. Today, Thinkforex scored higher than most ECN + commission brokers besides pepperstone. ILQ and PFG are at the bottom where PFG high spreads caused over a 100 pip difference from the broker leaders.
I’ll try to do this every month since brokers often change! Thanks for reading.










